About

Why this exists

I have sat through a great many mandatory compliance modules, and every single time I have had the same experience: I get one wrong that I was certain about, and the explanation for why I got it wrong is more interesting than anything else in the module. Not because the rule is stupid. Because the rule is precise, and precision does not feel like anything.

That turns out to be true of almost any system written down carefully enough to enforce.

  • A workplace can be exempt from every requirement of OSHA’s fire extinguisher standard by keeping no extinguishers at all, as long as everyone has to leave the moment the alarm sounds and the plans behind that policy are in order.
  • A rock covered in bird guano can fall inside federal criminal jurisdiction, if the President chooses to treat it as American.
  • A holiday gift card from your employer is taxable at any amount. A frozen turkey of the same value may not be.
  • When a witness can no longer remember what they once wrote down, the record can be read to the jury, but only the other side can put the page in the jury’s hands.
  • An NFL referee can award a touchdown that nobody scored, if a palpably unfair act is the reason nobody did.
  • At work, an equal-opportunity boor may fall outside federal discrimination law entirely.

None of that is a flaw in the system. It is what happens when a rule has to be written clearly enough to be enforced. But it does mean the codified version and the intuitive version part company almost immediately, and the gap between them is genuinely funny in the way that only true things are.

What this is

Assessments built the way real ones are built, each against a body of rules somebody actually wrote down: federal statutes, regulations and case law, and in one case the NFL rulebook. The fact patterns are invented to be as ridiculous as the format will bear. The absurdity is in the scenarios. It is never in the grading. Every explanation cites its primary source and the date that source was last checked, and is correct as far as I can make it, because a joke about how surprising the rules are only works if the rules are reported accurately.

The name

A reductio takes a rule at its word and follows it until the result stops making sense. The .us is the jurisdiction, and also the target: we are what is being reduced.

A rule I hold myself to

The fool in every scenario is the person exhibiting the behavior. Never the person the rules exist to protect. The absurdity lives in the codified system, not in anyone subject to it. That is not a disclaimer, it is a constraint on what gets written, and anything that fails it does not ship.

What this is not

Not training. Not legal, tax, or officiating advice. Not affiliated with any employer, agency, or league named here, and not a substitute for a professional who knows your facts. If you are making an actual decision with actual consequences, close this site and call one.

Built by

ksmith, an independent builder in Maryland. More at centricle.com.

No ads, no sponsored content, no affiliate links. Page views are counted; answers are not. Your certificate ID is the only record of an attempt, and it goes wherever you send it.